Aggravated Sexual Assault Charges in Toronto
Aggravated sexual assault is one of the most serious sexual offences under the Criminal Code. Section 273 applies where, during a sexual assault, the complainant is wounded, maimed, or disfigured, or their life is endangered.
Because the charge involves both the underlying sexual assault and an aggravating circumstance, the evidence supporting each part of the allegation must be examined carefully.
Free Confidential ConsultationWhat Is Aggravated Sexual Assault?
Under s. 273, the Crown must establish a sexual assault and one of the aggravating circumstances identified by the Code:
- Wounding
- Maiming
- Disfigurement
- Endangering the complainant’s life
The Crown must prove the required elements beyond a reasonable doubt. The nature of the alleged injury or danger, how it occurred, and the evidence connecting it to the alleged sexual assault can become central issues.
Contact Us
Different Types of Aggravated Sexual Assault Allegations
Alleged Wounding
The allegation may involve an injury associated with the sexual assault. Medical evidence can become important in determining the nature and cause of the injury.
Alleged Maiming or Disfigurement
The prosecution may rely on evidence concerning significant physical injury or lasting impairment or disfigurement.
Alleged Endangerment of Life
The charge can also arise where the allegation is that the complainant’s life was endangered during the sexual assault, even where the focus is not simply on the extent of a physical injury.
Firearm-Related Allegations
Additional sentencing provisions can apply where a firearm was used. The applicable minimum depends on the circumstances, including the type of firearm and other statutory factors.
Allegations Involving Serious Bodily Injury
Some cases involve substantial medical evidence, emergency treatment, photographs, expert opinions, or other records concerning the alleged injuries.
What Does the Crown Have to Prove?
An aggravated sexual assault charge is not established simply because serious injuries are alleged.
The defence may examine:
- Whether a sexual assault occurred
- Whether the accused was responsible
- The nature and extent of the alleged injury
- Whether the evidence establishes wounding, maiming, disfigurement, or life endangerment
- Medical and forensic evidence
- The timeline of events
- Witness accounts and credibility
- Whether the evidence establishes the required elements beyond a reasonable doubt
The precise legal issues depend on the allegations and evidence in the case.
Evidence in Aggravated Sexual Assault Cases
These cases can involve extensive physical and documentary evidence, including:
- Medical and hospital records
- Photographs of injuries
- DNA and forensic evidence
- Police photographs and reports
- Expert evidence
- Text messages and other communications
- Witness statements
- Previous statements
- Timeline and location evidence
Medical evidence should be examined in context. The existence of an injury does not, by itself, answer every legal question raised by the charge.
Credibility and Conflicting Accounts
Some cases involve significant differences between the complainant’s account and the accused’s account.
The defence may examine prior statements, changes in the allegations, surrounding communications, witness evidence, and whether independent evidence supports or contradicts either account.
Where credibility is central, careful preparation for cross-examination can be particularly important.
Bail and Release Conditions
Aggravated sexual assault allegations can create immediate issues involving arrest, detention, and release.
Depending on the circumstances, bail conditions may restrict:
- Contact with the complainant
- Contact with witnesses
- Where you can go or live
- Employment or other activities
- Travel
- Internet or electronic communication
Release conditions must be followed carefully. Speak with your lawyer before seeking to change or interpret a condition.
Consequences of an Aggravated Sexual Assault Conviction
Section 273 makes aggravated sexual assault an indictable offence punishable by life imprisonment. The Code also provides specific minimum penalties in certain circumstances, including particular firearm cases and where the complainant is under 16.
A conviction can also have consequences involving:
- A criminal record
- Sex-offender registration
- DNA orders
- Employment and professional licensing
- Immigration
- Travel
- Family and personal relationships
- Reputation
The actual consequences depend on the charge, circumstances, conviction, and sentence.
Aggravated Sexual Assault and Related Charges
Depending on the circumstances, the Crown may also allege other offences, including:
- Sexual Assault
- Sexual Assault with a Weapon or Causing Bodily Harm
- Sexual Interference
- Invitation to Sexual Touching
- Sexual Exploitation
- Historical Sexual Assault
- Other offences arising from the same incident
The distinction between s.272 and s.273 can be particularly important because aggravated sexual assault requires the additional circumstances specified in s.273.
How We Defend Aggravated Sexual Assault Charges
Goodman Berman approaches these cases by separating the allegations into the legal elements that must actually be proved.
Defence preparation may include:
- Reviewing disclosure and medical evidence
- Assessing forensic evidence and expert opinions
- Examining timelines and witness accounts
- Testing the reliability of competing accounts
- Identifying weaknesses in the prosecution’s evidence
- Addressing bail and release conditions
- Preparing for trial and cross-examination
The defence strategy is built around the specific evidence rather than the seriousness of the allegation alone.
What You Should Do If You Are Charged
If police want to question you, speak with a criminal defence lawyer before providing a substantive statement.
You should also avoid contacting the complainant, discussing the allegations with potential witnesses, posting about the case online, or deleting potentially relevant evidence.
Free Confidential ConsultationFrequently Asked Questions About Aggravated Sexual Assault Cases
What makes sexual assault “aggravated”?
Under s.273, the sexual assault must involve wounding, maiming, disfigurement, or endangering the complainant’s life.
Is aggravated sexual assault an indictable offence?
Yes. Section 273 makes aggravated sexual assault an indictable offence.
Can aggravated sexual assault result in life imprisonment?
Yes. Section 273 provides for a maximum sentence of life imprisonment. Specific minimum penalties can also apply in certain circumstances.
Does the complainant have to suffer permanent injuries?
Not necessarily. Section 273 refers to wounding, maiming, disfigurement, or endangering life. The legal significance of the alleged injury depends on the evidence and applicable law.
What if medical evidence does not match the allegation?
Medical evidence can be an important part of the defence analysis. Its significance depends on what the records actually establish and how that evidence fits with the other evidence in the case.
Can a case depend on credibility?
Yes. Where the evidence involves conflicting accounts, prior statements, communications, witnesses, and surrounding circumstances may all become relevant to assessing the case.
Can I get bail on an aggravated sexual assault charge?
Bail depends on the circumstances of the case and the applicable legal requirements. Conditions may be imposed if you are released.
Can an aggravated sexual assault charge affect my immigration or employment?
It can. A charge or conviction may create immigration, employment, professional licensing, travel, and reputational consequences depending on the circumstances.
What if the allegation happened years ago?
Historical allegations can still result in criminal proceedings. The defence should examine the available records, previous statements, witnesses, memory, and other evidence.
What should I do if police have contacted me?
Speak with a criminal defence lawyer before providing a substantive statement. Do not contact the complainant or alter potentially relevant evidence.
What Our Clients Say About Our Criminal Defence Team
Speak With an Aggravated Sexual Assault Lawyer in Toronto
If you are under investigation or have been charged with aggravated sexual assault, the evidence should be reviewed as early as possible.
At Goodman Berman, Barristers, our criminal defence lawyers can review the allegations, assess the evidence, identify potential weaknesses in the Crown’s case, and advise you on the best way forward.
Contact Goodman Berman, Barristers for a free, confidential consultation.
Your case will be reviewed directly by an experienced criminal defence lawyer.
Contact Goodman Berman, Barristers →
Get legal advice before making your next move.
1
Call Us
Free, confidential, no obligation
2
We review your case
Understand your charges & options
3
We defend you
Direct access to your lawyer throughout