Sexual Assault Causing Bodily Harm Charges in Toronto
Sexual assault causing bodily harm is an offence under section 272 of the Criminal Code. It applies where, in committing a sexual assault, the accused causes bodily harm to the complainant. Section 272 also covers certain allegations involving weapons, threats to a third party, choking, suffocation, strangulation, or participation with another person.
These cases can involve serious allegations and complex medical, forensic, and credibility evidence.
Free Confidential ConsultationWhat Is Sexual Assault Causing Bodily Harm?
Under s.272, the Crown must establish a sexual assault and the additional circumstance alleged.
For a bodily-harm charge, important questions can include:
- Did a sexual assault occur?
- Did the accused cause bodily harm?
- What was the nature and extent of the alleged injury?
- What evidence connects the injury to the alleged incident?
- Has the Crown proved every required element beyond a reasonable doubt?
The specific evidence and legal issues depend on the circumstances of the case.
Contact Us
Different Types of s.272 Allegations
Section 272 covers more than one type of aggravated sexual assault allegation.
Sexual Assault Causing Bodily Harm
The allegation is that a sexual assault caused bodily harm to the complainant.
Sexual Assault Involving a Weapon
The charge can arise where a weapon or imitation weapon was carried, used, or threatened to be used.
Threats to a Third Party
Section 272 also applies where the accused allegedly threatened bodily harm to someone other than the complainant.
Choking, Suffocation or Strangulation
The Code separately identifies choking, suffocating, or strangling the complainant as conduct covered by s.272.
Multiple-Accused Allegations
Section 272 can also apply where the accused is alleged to have participated in the offence with another person.
Bodily Harm and Medical Evidence
Medical evidence can become central in a sexual assault causing bodily harm case.
Depending on the allegation, the evidence may include:
- Hospital and medical records
- Photographs of injuries
- DNA or other forensic evidence
- Expert evidence
- Police photographs and reports
- Witness accounts
- Text messages or other communications
- Timeline and location evidence
The defence should examine what the medical evidence actually establishes and whether it is consistent with the prosecution’s account.
Consent and Credibility
Consent can be a central issue in a sexual assault prosecution. The defence may examine what was communicated or understood, the surrounding circumstances, prior and subsequent communications, and whether the Crown has proved the absence of consent as required by law.
Where the parties give different accounts, credibility may also become important. Previous statements, changes in the allegations, communications, witnesses, and independent evidence can all form part of the analysis.
Historical Sexual Assault Causing Bodily Harm Allegations
Some allegations are brought years after the alleged incident.
Historical cases may require careful review of:
- Previous statements
- Memory and recollection
- Medical or other records
- Witness availability
- Old communications
- Photographs or other evidence
- The timeline of the alleged events
- Evidence supporting or contradicting the allegation
The age of an allegation does not by itself determine the outcome. The available evidence must be assessed in the circumstances of the particular case.
Evidence and Defence Preparation
Goodman Berman can examine the prosecution’s case from both the underlying sexual-assault allegation and the additional s.272 circumstance.
Defence preparation may include:
- Reviewing disclosure and medical evidence
- Assessing forensic and expert evidence
- Examining timelines and witness accounts
- Identifying inconsistencies or evidentiary gaps
- Reviewing police conduct and potential Charter issues
- Preparing for cross-examination
- Addressing bail and release conditions
The defence strategy depends on the evidence and allegations in the individual case.
Bail and Release Conditions
Because these allegations can result in serious criminal proceedings, arrest and bail may become immediate concerns.
Release conditions may restrict:
- Contact with the complainant
- Contact with witnesses
- Where you can go or live
- Employment or other activities
- Travel
- Internet or electronic communication
Do not breach a release condition or attempt to arrange prohibited contact through someone else.
Consequences of a Conviction
Section 272 is an indictable offence. The maximum sentence can be 14 years’ imprisonment, with different and potentially more severe sentencing provisions in certain circumstances, including cases involving a complainant under 16 or firearm use.
A conviction can also affect:
- Criminal record
- Employment
- Professional licensing
- Immigration
- Travel
- Sex-offender registration
- DNA orders
- Family and personal relationships
- Reputation
The actual consequences depend on the charge, circumstances, conviction, and sentence.
Related Sexual Offences
Depending on the facts, related charges may include:
- Sexual Assault
- Aggravated Sexual Assault
- Sexual Interference
- Invitation to Sexual Touching
- Sexual Exploitation
- Historical Sexual Assault
- Other offences arising from the same circumstances
The distinction between s.272 and s.273 is particularly important. Section 273 concerns a sexual assault in which the complainant is wounded, maimed, or disfigured, or their life is endangered.
What You Should Do If You Are Charged
If police want to question you, speak with a criminal defence lawyer before providing a substantive statement.
You should also avoid contacting the complainant, discussing the case with potential witnesses, posting about the allegations online, or deleting potentially relevant evidence.
Free Confidential ConsultationFrequently Asked Questions About Sexual Assault Causing Bodily Harm
Does bodily harm have to be permanent?
Not necessarily. The significance of the alleged injury depends on the evidence and the applicable law. Medical records and other evidence may be important.
Is sexual assault causing bodily harm the same as aggravated sexual assault?
No. They are separate Criminal Code offences. Section 272 includes causing bodily harm, while s.273 involves wounding, maiming, disfigurement, or endangering the complainant’s life.
Can consent be an issue?
Yes. Consent can be an important issue in the underlying sexual-assault allegation, depending on the facts and applicable law.
What if the medical evidence does not support the allegation?
The defence can examine whether the medical evidence is consistent with the prosecution’s account and what conclusions can properly be drawn from it.
Can credibility determine the case?
Credibility can be important where the evidence involves conflicting accounts. Previous statements, communications, witnesses, and independent evidence may all be relevant.
Can I be charged years after the alleged incident?
Historical allegations can result in criminal proceedings depending on the circumstances and applicable law. The available evidence should be reviewed carefully.
Can I get bail on a s. 272 charge?
Bail depends on the circumstances and applicable legal requirements. If released, conditions may restrict contact, travel, residence, employment, or other activities.
Can a conviction affect my employment or immigration status?
It can. The consequences depend on your circumstances, profession, immigration status, and the outcome of the case.
What should I do if police contact me?
Speak with a criminal defence lawyer before providing a substantive statement. Do not contact the complainant or alter potentially relevant evidence.
What Our Clients Say About Our Criminal Defence Team
Speak With a Sexual Assault Causing Bodily Harm Lawyer in Toronto
If you are under investigation or charged under s.272, early review of the allegations and evidence can help identify the legal and factual issues in your case.
At Goodman Berman, Barristers, our criminal defence lawyers can review the allegations, assess the evidence, identify potential weaknesses in the Crown’s case, and advise you on the best way forward.
Contact Goodman Berman, Barristers for a free, confidential consultation.
Your case will be reviewed directly by an experienced criminal defence lawyer.
Contact Goodman Berman, Barristers →
Get legal advice before making your next move.
1
Call Us
Free, confidential, no obligation
2
We review your case
Understand your charges & options
3
We defend you
Direct access to your lawyer throughout